05/27/2010 (1:47 pm)
Conklin Dairy “Farm” Scandal – Who’s to blame?
I had planned on continuing the greenhouse saga today but something else has my blood boiling so I’ve decided to talk about it instead.
First, let me start by saying I will not even be posting the link to this video. It’s very disturbing and I don’t think any purpose will be served by sending you to it. If you really want to see it, just do a search for Conklin Dairy Farms. You’ll find it. Consider yourself warned.
Second, I don’t agree with the organization that did this “undercover investigation.” Mercy For Animals pushes an agenda of total veganism because they say using animals for food causes them nothing but misery. I obviously not only don’t subscribe to this idea but vehemently argue against it. I have issues with the way Mercy For Animals conducts business, but I’ll save that rant for another day.
Thirdly, the “farm” I’m about to discuss is not a farm. It’s not even a dairy operation. It’s a livestock wholesaler specializing in dairy cattle. Even though factory farming is disgusting to me on a whole, these people don’t fall into that category. So to say this type of abuse is prevalant throughout the dairy industry is wholly incorrect and misleading.
Now, the video I’m referring to shows workers at this company violently punching calves in the face, body slamming them to the ground, pulling and throwing them by their ears, using pitchforks to stab cows in the face, legs and stomach, beating restrained cows in the face with crowbars, twisting cows’ tails until the bones snapped and bragging about stabbing, dragging, shooting and beating cows and calves to death. The workers featured are malicious and sadistic. There is no excuse for what they did, but there also isn’t any excuse for the amount of footage the “investigators” from Mercy For Animals taped before they decided to turn it in. One day’s worth would have been enough, but they let this torture go on in order to bolster their cause. That’s almost as criminal to me as what the workers themselves were doing.
Regarding Conklin, they should be immediately shut down. There is no way the owners of this company (one of whom was shown beating a cow in the video) couldn’t have known this cruelty was happening and should be arrested right along side their employees.
But the bigger point is this: this is what happens when “farming” becomes industry. These workers, regardless of whether this is a dairy operation or not, have grown to see these animals as just another cog in the machine of producing our food. The cows and calves are no longer seen as deserving of any proper treatment or compassion for what they are doing for our food supply. We’ve seen it time and again in other operations, whether beef, dairy, chicken, eggs, or pork. It’s disgusting and is exactly why we do things the way we do on our own farm and in our lives.
The sensational journalism aside, I hope this video and the reports of what was happening there helps consumers to re-evaluate where and how they get their food. There is no reason for someone to go vegan purely for these reasons. It’s a personal choice and my choice is to raise animals with dignity and respect, be thankful to them for the food they provide and ensure they live as healthy and natural a life as possible in my care. I also search out companies that do the same and buy only from them. Believe me there are plenty of farms and large operations out there that treat their animals the right way, from start to finish. You just have to seek them out and actively buy from them and them only.
This goes right back to the acronym I teach people when I do presentations about buying local and eating sustainably. KURVE.
K – Know Your Source
U – Understand the Differences (between sustainable, organic, naturally raised, etc.)
R – Read About Their Practices
V – Visit the Farm (when possible)
E – Enjoy the Products
Bottom line is try to know where your food is coming from and make educated decisions. And be thankful to these animals for what they are giving us.
